Many people have asked me how and why I ended up researching the life of Johann Bessler, given that he was believed to be a charlatan, a faker and what we might call a scam or con artist. I have been told numerous times that Bessler deceived others by presenting a fraudulent offer as legitimate - and of course I was taught in school that perpetual motion machines would break the conservation of energy law.
He offered for sale his self- proclaimed Perpetual Motion machine, for a figure of £20,000 - a sum worth more than £3.5 million today. He didn’t just pluck this figure out of the air - it was the same sum of money offered in 1712, by the British Board of Longitude, for the first person to devise a way to establish a ship’s position at sea.
Bessler did not intend to enter for that prize but he did think that his invention, the Perpetual Motion machine, was worth at least as much and so he set the purchase price for his machine at the same figure.
The reason I decided to find out as much as I could about Bessler and his machine was down to a small piece of information I found in a book about the inventor which initially raised a question in my mind.
In a document dated 28th November 1727, Orffyreus' maid makes the following statement.
"The posts had been hollowed out and contained a long thin piece of iron with a barb at the bottom which was attached to the shaft journal.
Turning was carried out from Orffyreus' bedroom which was close to the machine, on a shelf behind the bed."
Strangely, it was these particular sentences, which have been quoted as one of the most vital pieces of evidence of the inventor's duplicity that eventually led me to begin my research.
I had already read a full and accurate account of the inventor and knew beyond a shadow of a doubt that what ever other negative evidence was produced concerning Bessler’s honesty, that of the maid quoted above was a lie. Her description of how the machine was made to rotate was, frankly, impossible.
We have so much information about all of these machines that Bessler demonstrated; the huge size of some of them, their speed, their capacity for lifting very heavy weights, and their demonstrable endurance to run without stopping for 54 days; that we can dismiss the maid’s evidence without hesitation.
In which case we are left with only the inventors demonstrations in front of numerous members of the public, including princes, councillors, university lecturers and Doctors. But there was one other witness of impeccable integrity. Karl the Landgrave of Hesse Kassel, was a man who was universally acknowledged to have strong moral principles who consistently demonstrated honesty and ethical behaviour . He was asked to grant his patronage and help Bessler to promote his invention by providing space in his castle.
Karl was shrewd and had good practical knowledge and the ability to make good judgements. He had invited Denis Papin to his court in Kassel in 1695 and supported his research for several years. Before he would agree to offer help of any kind to Bessler he insisted that he must be allowed to see the interior to check the inventor’s claims were genuine. Bessler reluctantly agreed and after completing a thorough examination of the device, Karl published a document asserting the legitimacy of the inventor’s claims.
That is briefly why I undertook this life long search. How I did it, is harder to explain.
Bessler was German, I knew no German! How was I to find all the documents I needed and translate them into English. It was at this point I realised this was going take a very long time, most of my life!
After several years of fragmented research I wrote as complete an account of the inventor as I could manage. This book, “Perpetual Motion; An Ancient Mystery Solved?”, is available - see below.
If the maid's testimony was about the big wheel at Weissenstein Castle, then it's a total load of bullsh*t. That wheel's vertical axle support beam ends were not in direct contact with the floor or the ceiling. They were separated from them by heavy iron pieces that created a gap big enough to insert one's hand into. Any thin metal rods going down through the center of a beam to power the wheel's axle end journals would have been obvious to those who examined the wheel prior to testing it and they would have immediately declared it a fake.
ReplyDeleteFrom your story it is obvious that you expended much effort to dig out the full Bessler story which prior authors did not do. It was a lot of work...but such is the price of getting recognition in any field. Unlike the average person out there, you will be remembered for it forever.
Brad
Thanks Brad. It was the Weissenstein wheel because further on in her statement she had to explain how she was forced to turn the wheel for 54 days with the help of Bessler, his brother, his wife and their 13 year old daughter. The statement was a record of a question and answer session she had to undergo after she accused him of fraud.
DeleteJC
That maid must have been thoroughly brainwashed by Bessler's enemies to lie under oath for them. Also a nice big financial bribe would have helped. She probably didn't really consider it a lie because they, claiming to be mechanical "experts", would have assured her that was exactly how Bessler MUST have faked his wheel demonstrations.
DeleteBessler should have made a publicly announced wager with all of his detractors. He'd get them together in the room with the wheel and uncover its hidden mechanisms for them. If it was a fake as they claimed it was, then Bessler would publicly admit that he was the lowest scum of the earth and that he'd hoaxed everyone hoping to steal their money with his fake pm wheel. Maybe Bessler could have convinced Karl to also pay them each 1,000 thalers for winning their wagers. But, if the wheel was genuine as Bessler claimed, then each of them would have to immediately pay him 5,000 thalers. Each would have to have his 5,000 thalers with him and be ready to pay Bessler if he lost his bet. With twenty of them in the room imagine their shock when each realized he'd just lost his money! The big secret would finally be revealed and Bessler would have immediately collected the 100,000 thalers he thought he deserved for his invention. The news of that would have quickly spread all over Europe and soon after everyone would have been building Bessler type pm wheels to put to work on farms, in factories, and in mines.
It's truly amazing how a lot of loud mouth skeptic types suddenly become quiet when they are challenged to put their money where their mouths are!
Nice idea but it wouldn’t work for several reasons.
DeleteFirstly, the maid was a thoroughly nasty piece of work. When Bessler got Dr Shoemacher’s blessing to marry his daughter and was given a dowry he was told he had to take his wife’s maid with him and keep her there as his new wife’s maid, as part of his agreement.
The reason for this was because the Doctor was also the Mayor and had been forced to imprison the maid on two separate occasions for spreading malicious gossip about him. She was released after she had begged for forgiveness, promising never to do it again. Obviously she couldn’t help her self and was soon spreading lies again.
Also Bessler was paranoid about maintaining the secret of his machine and would never accept the idea that you proposed - he had extreme difficulty in allowing Karl to see inside his machine, but he had no choice in that case if he wanted Karl on his side.
There is so much more to say about the maid and her previous employers but not here.
JC
Look no further than the earlier Merseburg translocation tests between two sets of floor to ceiling wheel supports in the same room, and where everything was carefully examined before and after.
ReplyDeleteExactly!
DeleteJC
Also, IIRC, his June 1712 demo with the Gera wheel was done outdoors in a public square. He had it mounted on some sort of portable wooden frame. No way to fake that. The evidence for his wheels being genuine far outweighs any evidence that they were faked, imo.
DeleteI think you remember incorrectly, there were no outside open air demonstrations. We wish there had been. On the tray of a moveable cart would have been just as good.
DeleteIt's hard to know exactly where Bessler's Gera wheel was first demonstrated. But, his wheels apparently could be used outdoors. The Merseburg wheel was going to be demonstrated at a fair and probably inside some sort of enclosure or tent. But that was cancelled due to an illness that he got. I vaguely recall mention of him offering to set a wheel up outside in a field to show how it was portable and could be used to drain flooded coal mines.
DeleteOn the 6th of June 1712, in Gera/Thuringia, on the premises of the “Richter Freihaus”, he presented for the first time a weight-driven wheel that turned for an unlimited time. The Richter Freihaus is the place where Bessler's wheel was presented to an audience for the first time in 1712. “Freihaus” used to have a privileged status. They often belonged to nobles who did not need to pay taxes to the city where the house was located and which was directly subject to the jurisdiction of the respective country. As the largest town house of Gera constructed of stone on the Nicolausberg, only its wooden components, including the roof, were destroyed during the fire of 1686.
DeleteThe second wheel was also demonstrated in a building, in the manor, when Bessler stayed in Draschwitz from 1713 to 1714 and where both Moritz Wilhelm of Saxe-Zeitz and Gottfried Leibniz personally took a close look at the wheel.
The Merseburg and Weissenstein wheels were fixed to the ceiling indoors.
JC
"On the premises of..." does not necessarily mean inside of a building. It could have been on the street in front of the building or in its backyard if it had one. I'd like to see a translation of the newspaper that printed an announcement of that June 6th demonstration. I have trouble imagining an "audience" of maybe up to a hundred interested people crowding into a building and into one room to see the wheel.
DeleteI can only copy and paste from my biography of Bessler which I published in 2005
Delete“They set up home in the town of Gera, the same town that was to witness the
first exhibition of the Orffyrean perpetual motion. Initially they lived at his
cousin's house, and it was here that Orffyreus began to construct his new
machine. However he found that none of the rooms in the house were big
enough for what he had in mind, so he took a lease on another house which
had much larger rooms. The problem was that living with his cousin,
Orffyreus worried that his secret might be accidentally revealed - it would be
difficult to work without risking someone coming in seeing something he did
not want them to see. As well, he would have needed space to work, and it
may have been crowded with two families living together. It is probable that
this was just a temporary arrangement until the newly-weds could afford
something more permanent.
The leased house was owned by Herr Richter and stood on Niclaus Hill, and
the inventor actually constructed his first demonstration model here in the
year 1712, exhibiting it on the 6th June. The device stood three, to three and
a half feet high (a little over one metre). I should point out here that all
measurements are approximate because each town had different systems of
24
measurement regarding both weight and distance. The wheel "was
mounted in such a fashion that anyone could walk all the way around it. On
unfastening a bolt, the wheel immediately began to revolve. Whoever
wished to push it or touch it at any point was free to do so. People could see
there was no trickery involved".
JC
One condition of the Merseburg translocation test was that it be conducted outdoors. Wagner writes that this condition was withdrawn.
ReplyDeleteGiven Bessler’s apparent paranoia about keeping the secret of the wheel’s construction, I see little reason to expect that he would even consider exhibiting his machine out side.
DeleteJC
Dear Mr Collins-
ReplyDeleteyou have done some amazing research work - prior to the Internet this must have been almost nightmarish. Getting material from libraries was difficult then.
I am German and only have been onto Bessler for about a month now. Since much of the material on the internet is second hand - and also second rate- I have decided to go for the origins and tried to download the original texts. It all is digitized and available on the web now. Apologia, Triumphans and the Machine tractates as well as Wagners material and many original documents signed by the witnesses and the Landgraf himself. The handwriting is very difficult to read but after a while one gets used to it. Even the Mauersperger lawsuit is on the web. I agree that this is a blatant lie.
I have decided to go completely against the grain and start with the work hypothesis that the large final wheel was driven by a hidden source of energy. To achieve this is almost as remarkable as inventing the perpetual movement itself. For the time! It means that Bessler has found a way to hide the "movens" inside the wheel - a "discovery proof" method from the outside but also from the inside as well since the Landgraf saw the interior and did not see any fraud. Out the window go all the easy solutions a la Wagner - ! On the other hand it emerges that the famous sealed test run of the wheel was WITHOUT LOAD. Just keeping the wheel going. The "Pochwerk" hammers might have been part of the mechanism. What is amazing is the high rotation speed of 26 rpm.
Then I decided to submit the whole thing to ChatGPT- not so much hoping for a solution but for the capacity of the AI to find hidden structures we cannot see.
The result is interesting. An "impulse drive" . Something that just shoves or pushes the wheel when it starts to loose speed. Getting over the "dead point" - that is the principle every pendulum clock works with and it can go for weeks with just one spring. Very little energy is needed. This goes up exponentially once the machine would be under load-.
Now my Bessler research is only a month old- but I have a rather good knowledge of the whole "free energy" field and built several electrical devices myself. Just for the fun of it.
To look for a solution similar to what Chat GPT suggests I would recommend to look into the "perpetual machine" of the Norvegian artist REIDAR FINSRUD. The principles used there could be the cue to Bessler- chaos pendulums and the search for constant des-equilibrium- here it is done with magnets but it can be done many other ways. Finsrud may have a hidden source of energy, too- his machine could go for years on end on a simple 9 Volt battery block...
I would like to correspond with you on several points- I tried to download the books but the paypal link does not work for me- no email address can be given.
Thanks for the great inspiration and thorough research!
Albert
Again me- I believe the solution to the riddle is a resonating system. Resonance is an incredible force. Perhaps the drum of Besslers wheel was a resonator. If you connect two harps by their resonance points with a wooden bar, and start to play a melody on harp one, harp two will begin to synchronize and the strings will move in the same way the strings move on harp one. Or think of the famous Tacoma bridge accident- a bridge begins to sway wildly because its resonant frequency happens to be the same as the frequency of the wind in a narrow valley. The Tacoma bridge broke up and fell into the river.
DeleteOr see this video-
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t-_VPRCtiUg