Johann claimed knowledge in a number of skills, indeed he went out of his way to try to learn as much as he could about every known trade in existence in his time. How much skill in each craft he actually acquired is impossible to know, but he does claim to have been a quick learner. Although it takes years to develop fully all the skills required in each trade - and particularly in those days, skilled craftsmen had to work through apprenticeships lasting several years - he only wanted to discover enough about each craft to understand what material and what tools were used and how they might answer his needs. Consequently he travelled widely searching for design ideas as well as tools and methods of construction. His claimed list of knowledge about various crafts can be seen as below.
His proudest claim seems to be that he could be called a Cleric, a Doctor and finally a Mathematician, but I'm certain these were self-granted titles to demonstrate his assessment of his personal talents.
In his Apologia Poetica he described how he studied mechanics, and ruthlessly picked the brains of anyone who might be of use. He "toiled endlessly at his creations, sculpting, grinding glass, smelting, casting and turning. Sculpting provided a range of unique tools, and even grinding glass might require some special revolving holding device. Smelting and casting could provide for the manufacture of lead and brass weights and turning can apply to both brass-work as well as wood.
He acquired skills in clock-making, glass-blowing, painting pictures and copper-engraving. He learned the art of enamelling and wax-modelling. He became knowledgeable about astronomy, and the surveying of woods, meadows and fields. He worked with gunpowder and constructed guns, claiming that he was a good shot himself. He studied music and learned to play some instruments. Clearly he did have some knowledge of music as can be seen in his design for a carillon for which he even included a musical score.
His teacher, Christian Weise, aimed to prepare his students for employment at the court or municipal offices and as such he gave them the tools to achieve these positions, hence the odd selection of skills he deemed apt.
Was there no end to this man's accomplishments? Apparently not. He became temporarily apprenticed to an Apothecary and learned some medicine and several cures. I believe that he used one of these cures to cure the mayor of Annaberg's daughter, Barbara whom he subsequently married.
It seems that during his travels he picked up a smattering of several languages - he seem to have had some aptitude in such things - and during an extended visit to Prague became acquainted with a Jesuit priest and Jewish rabbi who taught him somee Hebrew, and ancient hieroglyphics, plus "the language of nature and the writings of angels".
Later in Dresden he pretended that he was an apprentice miller and picked up their milling jargon. In the process he learned much about their techniques such as whetting millstones and replacing their bearings.
The final and perhaps most useful craft he chose to examine was that of the church organ maker, and for this he turned to a relative who was an artist, organ-maker and turner. The organ of that period was probably the largest and most complex machine ever constructed to that time. There was an organ that was in the Invalidenhaus chapel in Karlshafen, which was said to have been built by Bessler. The chapel was used by the evangelical community until they had their own church built at Karlshafen in 1960. At which point the organ was donated to the new church - St. Stephanus Church. A new organ was built by Werner Bosch in 1963 incorporating all the usable pipes from the old Invalidenhaus organ. So it seems the old Bessler organ was destroyed to make the new one! Perhaps they kept the rest of the old parts somewhere?
It seems as though Bessler set himself on this path before he actually had an aim in mind and it might indicate a natural curiosity about all these subjects. His former headmaster, Christian Weise, has an excellent reputation both as a teacher, administrator and playwright and interestingly he has stated that Bessler was his star pupil.
So one would think that if anybody was going to solve the problem of designing and building a perpetual motion machine it would be Johann Bessler - and he did.
PS I almost forgot his ability to speak, write and compose poetry in both German and Latin.
PS I almost forgot his ability to speak, write and compose poetry in both German and Latin.
JC
I wholeheartedly agree with you John. Johann paid his dues and deserved to discover the correct geometry and mechanism which made the gravity propelled wheel possible. He understood human nature so who can blame him for his preoccupation with safeguarding his discovery? Didn't he deserve to be compensated for all of his years of sacrifice and hard work? It's sad and ironic that the very force that brought him such fame, though not fortune, ended up killing him.
ReplyDeleteDoes anyone know what would be a good material to make weights out of? I want to make a mold so that I can make duplicate weights for my gravity wheel. The mold is easy to make. I can just use 100% silicone and cornstarch mixed together. I'm going to take the least expensive route on this one. Does anyone have any ideas that they've tried? I want to mix together some type of material to pour into the molds.
ReplyDeleteYou can buy small tubs of concrete (for erecting posts) at low cost. When you mix it with water, it bonds with the material and so once dried out, has a higher weight than the powder mix due to the bonded water, which forms the crystal growths that give it its strength... You can make molds from anything, and once set the concrete can be sanded or filed down to precise weights.
DeleteI also buy small rolls of lead flashing - flat lead sheeting, about 4 mm thick, used for roofing - you can get both products from builders merchants. The lead can be quite easily cut or just torn, and then rolled into little cylinders or folded into thicker lumps. Cut into little squares it's easy to pin or glue into place, too.
You don't say.
DeleteVibrator now offers construction advice in lieu of massive expositions of theoretical technicalia. (Don't get me wrong. Much of it I've found of positive resultant use.)
Would this change be a step backward or forward, or neither?
Well, whichever it may turn out to be, work for a physically-manifesting asymmetry such that will provide an uneven division of energy output interiorly per identical amounts in exteriorly, as a function of rotatory direction.
THEN you will have it. Without never, dying baffled to the end.
(This little advisement is a definitive statement based upon knowledge, possessing nothing whatever of the mere theoretical about it. As to it Bessler was clear, like crystal . . . IF you know how to see when finally come-unstuck from yourself.)
Did THAT get your uppity attention or, are you to act the bone-head to the very end? Hmm?
John, where is everyone? No one seems to be commenting like they used to. Maybe they're waiting for you.....
ReplyDeleteor me to finally announce that EUREKA moment.
steel peening shot is a good candidate because epoxy will attach easily. Silicone rubber mold is pretty easy to make as well. John.... I believe that I read somewhere that Bessler was asked to come and TWEEK a trebuche' mechanism. can you shed any light on that?
ReplyDeleteNews to me, I don't know anything about it.
DeleteJC
Thanks Gravittea. I have plenty of copper coated steel BB's, and they have quite a bit of weight to them. I believe I'll do a test to see how it works😁
ReplyDeleteJust saw a video that almost makes me thing I should just quit looking for the solution, has this guy got it? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ePH6vkqAeB4&feature=youtu.be
ReplyDeleteThink.
DeleteIt's a fake video. If you look closely at the guy that runs up to the, you'll see that he leans over and holds his shirt from blowing. You can actually see the ripples in his shirt as if a LEAF BLOWER is blowing his shirt and at the same time spinning the wheel. Nice try though.😉
DeleteUpdated:
ReplyDeleteIt's a fake video. If you look closely at the guy that runs up to the wheel, you'll see that he leans over and holds his shirt from blowing. You can actually see the ripples in his shirt as if a LEAF BLOWER is blowing his shirt and at the same time spinning the wheel. Nice try though.😉
I bet that if you were to place that liquid gravity wheel in a plexiglass box that is completely sealed, it wouldn't even spin. Maybe I can and should provide a video of a true working gravity wheel. I have to make 15 more weights and then put it all together. Like John, I'm very determined to prove that a gravity powered wheel is possible. To bad there isn't some sort of prize money for proving that a true gravity wheel can work, because I sure could use the money😁
ReplyDeleteIt's funny, there's an X Prize for building reusable rockets or planes, but they don't have one for gravity powered wheels. Boo hoo😞
I am still extremely curious about Bessler's comment that the secret is used by children everywhere. There is quite a list, but somehow I have come up with the Yo Yo. Been really noodling this for a while
ReplyDeleteMaybe John can provide the exact wording and context.
ReplyDeleteI am puzzled about this comment. I have been unable to find any reference to it in any of the books, and yet I seem to recall it from somewhere - any suggestions?
DeleteJC
Hello John, I wanted to share something with you. I was reading your comment and another comment that someone had asked about, children's toys. Well, I just looked it up on Google, about children's toys from the 18th century. And one thing that I noticed as I was looking at the pictures, is a small odd looking shaped toy almost like a spinning top. And this spinning top had a whole on the side of it so that you could see inside. Now, on one of the Bessler's toy pages, you see a little upside down looking spinning top with a hole in it. Could this be a clue?
DeleteJohn, it comes from Wagner's Second Critique, which you have on your site. "Finally, Herr Orffyreus supposedly gets to the root of the matter when he asserts that children in the lane play with his perpetual motion or so-called superior force. Here I am in complete agreement with him and say that not only does his principle appear in all books on mechanics, but most people in the world have seen it, and children in the lane do indeed play with it often."
DeleteIf anyone is interested, Leonhard Euler's books on mechanics etc. can be found at the Euler Archive.
DeleteBessler's comment about children using it everywhere could be of that about the see-saw..
ReplyDeleteCould "children using it" imply a force such CF, or perhaps a type of movement that produces a force such as the whip or two kids holding hands spinning around until they can't hold any longer and fly apart. Lots of ways to interpret what "using it" could mean.
DeleteI believe the most common toy or device that children used back then and even today was the swing. The swine was more fun and was used more often than a see-saw. So, maybe we should look further into this device and utilize it's movement into the gravity wheel.
ReplyDeleteMy apologies for not being able to recall where the comment originated, thank you anon.3rd June. Of course it was from Wagner's second critique. I believe it was suggested that the toy that children used in the street was the hoop and stick - maybe?
DeleteJC
Yes John,
ReplyDeleteKids played hoops by racing metal or wooden hoops along the ground with their hands or sticks. The hoops were often salvaged from old barrels.The object of the game was to keep the hoop rolling as long as possible and get to the finish line first.
Appreciate everyones thoughts on this question. The next is the toy with the window on the side, it is definitely on his toys page but I have not been able to find it and have no idea what it does...
ReplyDelete